River Bend Farm Master Egg Casserole

“One of the hardest things for an innkeeper or hostess is finding an egg recipe that will hold well. This one will keep on the table for about an hour!” River Bend Farm, Williamstown, Massachusetts


3 cups milk
6 large eggs
1 teaspoon dry mustard (Coleman's is recommended)
Unsalted butter
Stuffing mix (Pepperidge Farm herbed stuffing is recommended, but even stale bread will work, cut into 1/2-inch cubes, but the cook will need to improvise with herbs and spices)
12 ounces mild sausage meat (Jimmy Dean is recommended)
10 ounces whole leaf spinach, fresh or frozen
8 ounces grated Vermont sharp cheddar cheese


Whisk the milk, eggs, and mustard in a bowl and set aside.
Butter an 8-cup-capacity oval gratin dish or other suitable refrigerator-to-oven-to-table container. Cover the bottom with half the stuffing mix or bread pieces.
In a medium-sized saucepan, boil the sausage briefly in water. Drain in a colander, breaking up the meat, and let cool. Distribute the meat in an even layer over the top of the stuffing or bread, spread the spinach over that, and gently pour the egg-milk mixture over all. Grind pepper over the top and sprinkle with the cheese. Cover with plastic wrap and refrigerate 8 hours or more.
Bake in a preheated 350 degree oven for 60 to 75 minutes or until the top is brown and puffy. Serve immediately.

VARIATION: Substitute ham for sausage, shredded zucchini for spinach, change the cheese, add a little nutmeg; it's versatile, easy, and fun. The important things are to use what's seasonally available, use the 2 eggs to 1 cup milk custard ratio, and allow the casserole to sit for at least 8 hours to soak the bread and blend the flavors.

Cooking & Recipes


Serves 12

Preparation Method


Add new comment

How much milk, and do you

How much milk, and do you only use half of the bag of stuffing mix?

In the last lines it says to

In the last lines it says to use the "2 eggs to 1 cup of milk ratio", so this recipe would start with 3 cups of milk. I would think you'd use the entire bag of stuffing, but I would start with half, then add a little at a time until it seems like enough. A recipe like this gives you a little bit of leeway.

3 cups of milk The amount of

3 cups of milk
The amount of stuffing will depend on the size of your baking dish. You can play around and see what works best.