Already a successful lobsterman at 18, Jack Newick began buying up land around Dover Point, piece by piece, in the 1940s. More than six decades later, his one-time lobster shack is now a seafood beacon, accommodating up to 600 people at a time and promising a romantic sunset from just about any seat in the house. People make the trek from far south and west to crack open a steamed lobster or gobble up the excellent fried seafood. But the rich seafood chowder—one of six “chowdahs” on the menu—is such a hit that it has to be made off-site. You can get your chowder the “original” way, teeming with bay scallops, shrimp, clams, and haddock—but insiders know to ask for added lobster, which turns this chowder into something like a seafood tour de force. Consider cooking and chilling the lobsters a day before preparing the chowder, to make it easier to remove the meat. But be sure to reserve the cooking water, which you’ll use to simmer the potatoes.
Fill a lobster pot halfway with water and bring to a boil over high heat. Add the lobsters, cover, and reduce the heat to medium; cook 8 minutes. Remove the lobsters and set them aside to cool. Reserve 4½ cups of the lobster water. When lobsters are cool and easy to handle, remove the meat from the claws, claw joints, and tails. Chop the meat coarsely and set aside. Put 4 cups of the reserved lobster water in a 2- to 3-quart pot, add the potatoes, and simmer until tender, 5 to 7 minutes. Drain and set aside. In a skillet over medium heat, fry the bacon, turning occasionally, until cooked but not crisp, 8 to 10 minutes. Set aside. Melt the butter in a 4- to 6-quart pot over medium-low heat. Add the onion and celery, and cook, stirring, until tender, 6 to 8 minutes. Add the bacon and cook another 3 minutes. Add the flour gradually, whisking continuously, to make a roux. Reduce the heat to low and continue stirring 5 minutes. Increase the heat to medium and slowly whisk in the remaining ½ cup of lobster water, then the bottled clam juice and the cream. Add the scallops, clam meat with its juices, haddock, and shrimp. Stir in the cooked potatoes, milk, salt, and pepper. Reduce the heat to low and simmer, stirring occasionally, until all the fish has cooked through and flavors have combined, about 15 minutes. Right before serving, add the lobster meat. Garnish with parsley or paprika.