The Freshest Blueberry Pie Ever Recipe

January 29, 2019
Blueberry Pie
Catherine Boeckmann

Rate this Post: 

Average: 3.7 (15 votes)

It’s blueberry season! Once again, I made one of the delicious “freshest pies ever” that my Almanac colleague recommended a couple years ago. The flakey crust just came out of the oven. Yum! The trick with the filling is to keep some of the berries uncooked before they go into the pie shell for baking.

I used 100% blueberries, but you can mix in other berries, too (such as raspberries). It’s so easy—and less messy than a two-cruster, too.

My son had been asking to go berry picking ever since he read the classic children’s book, Blueberries for Sal by Robert McCloskey. (If you don’t grow or pick your own berries, get the freshest berries available from the grocery store.)

I can’t get enough of this native fruit, not just for their taste but also because of blueberries’ amazing health benefits.

We visited a local berry farm with 12 acres dripping in berries. When we returned home, we had what turned out to be 8 cups of blueberries (and a cup in each of our tummies!).

Tip: If you bring a bucket and a belt, you can loop the bucket through the belt to leave both hands free to pick! When blueberries are at their peak, the bushes are loaded and there’s no easier fruit to pick.

Since berries don’t last long, we started making our pie right away.

The Very Freshest Blueberry Pie Recipe


1 9-inch single crust
4 cups blueberries
⅔ to 1-½ cups sugar to taste
¼ cup cornstarch
1 cup water
1 tablespoon lemon juice
2 tablespoons butter


  • Bake pie crust.
  • Pour ⅔ cup sugar, cornstarch, and water in a saucepan. Mix until smooth.
  • Add 1-½ cups blueberries and cook over medium heat, about 7 to 10 minutes, stirring occasionally until mixture is thick and semitransparent.
  • Stir in lemon juice, then butter.
  • Turn off the stove. Let the mix in the saucepan cool off.
  • Stir in the remaining fresh blueberries.
  • Taste, and add more sugar to taste, if necessary.
  • Pour into baked pie shell and chill until firm.
  • Serve with sweetened, vanilla-flavored whipped cream.

Tip: Don’t forget to let the saucepan cool a little, or the fresh berries will cook and get all syrupy like grocery-store pies.

The pie was so juicy and flavorful! We didn’t have the whipped cream, so we paired the pie with vanilla bean ice cream. The berries literally explode with juiciness. (My son realized why we chew with our mouth closed … to avoid blueberry stains!)

I rarely make fruit pies, but this is the only berry pie I’ll make from now on.

We still have a lot of berries left and will freeze them. In the book Blueberries for Sal, the parents canned all of the blueberries to last through winter. Perhaps we’ll make some jam!  What do you make with blueberries?

About This Blog

Here at the Almanac, we love to cook, bake, grill, roast, and eat! We'll show you how to make some delicious recipes.

2020 Almanac Calendar Club