5 Types of Sugar Cookies: Find Your Match

Which sugar cookie recipe is your favorite?

December 6, 2016
Favorite Sugar Cookies Collection
Leigh Anne Meeks

What’s your favorite sugar cookie: Soft and pillowy? Cut-outs for decorating? Grandma’s cookies? See 5 easy sugar cookie recipes from scratch and find your match! Or try them all and do a taste test!

Pre-made cookie dough can have a strange, almost chemical-like aftertaste. These homemade sugar cookies have the tender, homemade taste that you’ll want to sink your teeth into!

Ethel’s Sugar Cookies

Looking for a thick and cakey iced sugar cookie? This is the famous sugar cookie recipe—from the Betty Crocker Cooky Book—that we make every year and includes an icing recipe. They remind us of the sugar cookies that we ate as children. It has a great “bite” with just the right amount of sweetness and a hint of vanilla. The combination of butter and shortening creates a nice sturdy dough that’s easy to roll with a rolling pin.

ethel-cookie-shutterstock_70112560_full_width.jpg
Credit: Cheryl E. Davis/Shutterstock

Classic Sugar Cookie Cut-Out

These are the easy classic sugar cookie cut-outs which are golden in color, crisp and light—perfect for cookie cutters. They hold their shape and also freeze well, unfrosted. Decorate with frosting or, if desired, with colored sugars, sprinkles, etc.

recipe-sugar_cookie_cutouts.jpg
Credit: Sam Jones/Quinn Brein

Soft Sugar Cookies

If you love the round, puffy sugar cookie, this recipe is for you! These nicely spiced cookies have an excellent flavor and texture without anything extra. Kids love rolling the balls in the sugar and squishing them down on the baking sheet.

sugar-round-shutterstock_628443425_full_width.jpg
Credit: Africa Studio/Shutterstock

Honey Cutout Cookies

A healthy dose of whole-wheat flour and honey gives this classic a wholesome twist. The flavor isn’t too sweet and the texture is very easy to work with for rolling and cutting out shapes. The cinnamon taste is just enough, not too strong. Decorate with frosting if you wish (recipe included).

recipe-honeycookies.jpg
Image: Sarah Perreault (baker); Photo credit: Aimee Tucker.

My Favorite Sugar Cookies

For the overachiever, make sugar cookie ornaments with our recipe from the Almanac Best Home Baking cookbook. You have a choice here: Roll and cut the cookies in the traditional way or shape the dough into logs and slice. 

recipe-sugar_cookie_snowflakes.jpg
Credit: Becky Luigart-Stayner

Lemon Sugar Cookies

Bonus! These delicate and delicious Lemon Sugar Cookies are bursting with fresh citrus flavor. Sugar cookies are always a favorite and the addition of lemon raises them to a higher (and tastier) level!

lemon-sugar-cookies.jpg
CrediteZeePics/shutterstock

For more delicious recipes, see our Easy Christmas Cookies!

christmas-kids-1073567_1280_full_width.jpg

almanac_cookbooks_ad_0.png

Leave a Comment