Check out our classic Christmas dessert recipes—from mince pies to stollen and sticky toffee pudding, as well as our easy chocolate yule cake and fun Christmas cookies. Oh, and old-fashioned gingerbread! Without further ado, here are our best Christmas baking ideas.
Christmas Dessert Recipes
Christmas Cakes and Puddings
Best Fruitcake Ever
Forget those horrible commercial fruitcakes. This is an easy, moist, delicious cake using dried fruits instead of the standard candied and glacéed fruits. Not only are dried fruits more readily available at your local market, but they also have a deeper and more natural flavor (not as sweet).
Image: Anna Shepulova/Shutterstock
Bûche de Noël (Chocolate Yule Log)
Try this easier, lighter version of the traditional chocolate Yule log! It’s a show-stopping dessert and fun to make.
Image: David P. Smith/Shutterstock.
Sticky Toffee Pudding with Butterscotch Sauce
A scrumptious treat for all ages, this sticky toffee pudding is sure-fire hit at any Christmas feast. Note: Normally baked in a pan but you can also make individual ramekins.
Image: Becky Luigart-Stayner
Classic Christmas Stollen
A lovely version of an old favorite. Tastes best served warm. Decorate with whole candied cherries, and use other candied fruit pieces to make leaves and stems.
This is an authentic, hundred-year-old recipe that’s wonderful served warm with a scoop of French vanilla ice cream or sprinkled with confectioners’ sugar.
Image: Marie C Fields/Shutterstock
Christmas Pies and Tarts
If you don’t like mince pie, you actually haven’t had the authentic thing! Learn more about “real” mince pie and find a recipe …
Mini Cranberry-Apple Pies
These Cranberry-Applies are sweet, yet tart. What a great combination in one pie! Single-serving pies work really well at a holiday gathering or dinner party; they’re easy to make, attractive, and guests love them.
Mini-Cranberry Apple Pies.
Cranberry Dream Pie
This icy-cold Cranberry Dream Pie is sure to be a hit at any table. Made ahead of time and waiting in the freezer, it’s like having an ace up your sleeve.
Cranberry Dream Pie. Photo by Sam Jones/Quinn Brein.
Christmas Cookies and Bars
Really Old-Fashioned Gingerbread People
This recipe for “Really Old-Fashioned Gingerbread People” makes a large batch because, well, anything this good deserves to be made in bulk. A few well-placed bits of candy or nuts for eyes and a nose will give your creations delightful personalities.
Pistachio-Cranberry Icebox Cookies
With their red-and-green color scheme, these sweets are perfect for the holidays.
Image: Ginger Nikole Vaughan/Quinn Brein
Spiced Sinterklaas Cookies (Speculaas)
Traditionally, speculaas are served on the eve of St. Nicholas Day or on the feast day itself (December 6), but we enjoy them throughout the holiday season.
Speculaas cookies. Photo by Sam Jones/Quinn Brein.
Ethel’s Sugar Cookies
A classic sugar cookie recipe that’s perfect for making cut-outs. Super easy, too! See more Easy Sugar Cookie Recipes.
Candy Cane Dessert Squares
This crowd-sized recipe can be served frozen or refrigerated, making it ideal for a holiday buffet.
Image: Sam Jones/Quinn Brein
Bring the snow indoors with these classic snowball cookies!
Never-Fail Christmas Fudge
Even if you’ve never made candy before in your life, give this easy fudge recipe a try. True to its name (thanks to the presence of marshmallows), it won’t seize or crumble or make you tear your hair out. It’s a tasty treat perfect for Christmastime!
Never-Fail Christmas Fudge. Photo by GreenArt/Shutterstock.
Simple, yet delicious, this peanut brittle is a tasty classic. For variety, mix in a cup of almonds with the peanuts!
Image: Janet Hudson
More Christmas Recipe Collections
What are your favorite holiday desserts to make (or eat)? Tell us in the comments below!