Thanksgiving Side Dish Recipes

Traditional Side Dishes and More!

November 19, 2018
homemade green bean casserole
Sam Jones/QuinnBrein

Thanksgiving side dishes make the meal! We have some delicious options—from the historically-inspired to modern-day classics to vegetarian options. Make the most of the harvest bounty!

Historically-Inspired Sides

The first Thanksgiving probably didn’t include many of our classics today from cranberries to mashed potatoes. (See more in Why We Eat Turkey on Thanksgiving.)

They were more likely to have chestnuts, squash, corn, and beans on hand, not potatoes, so we have included some historically-inspired side dishes.

Classic Succotash

It’s quite likely the Pilgrims and the Wampanoags ate this dish which features a mix of beans and corn. The word succotash comes from the Wampanoag msíckquatash, meaning “boiled corn kernels.”

shutterstock_506036521_full_width.jpg
Homemade Succotash with Lima Beans, Corn, and Bacon. Credit: Brent Hofacker/Shutterstock

Chestnut Croquettes

At the time of the first Thanksgiving in 1621, there were certainly chestnuts in the forest. This recipe for Chestnut Croquettes is very simple, and makes a lovely accompaniment to turkey or goose.

shutterstock_132057926_full_width.jpg
Goose leg with croquette and orange sauce. Credit: Ryzhkov Photography/Shutterstock

Classic Thanksgiving Sides

We love the colorful, healthy hues of today’s Thanksgiving food from red cranberries to deep orange sweet potatoes to vibrant green Brussels sprouts (provided they’re not overcooked!). Here are some of our favorite sides.

Cornbread Stuffing

This classic Cornbread Stuffing (pictured below) is a favorite on the holiday table. Our recipe will stuff a 15 to 18 pound turkey. For other options, check out our Cornbread and Sausage Stuffing and our Potato Lovers Stuffing! If you make a cornbread stuffing, we would substitute dinner rolls for cornbread in your menu. 

cornbread_stuffing.jpg
Credit: Sam Jones/QuinnBrien

Pecan-Crusted Sweet Potato Casserole

The pecan crunch adds some great texture to this dish and the Thanksgiving meal. For more sweet potato options, see our Mashed Sweet Potatoes and this old-fashioned Sweet Potato Soufflé.

sweet-potato-pecan-casserole_full_width.jpg
Credit: Becky Luigart-Stayner

Basic Cranberry Sauce

If you’d like to make a homemade sauce, this one’s basic and beloved. For something a little more creative, try our Chai-Spiced Orange-Cranberry Sauce

cranberry_sauce.jpg
Credit: Anna Shepulova/shutterstock

Mashed Potatoes With Chives

Chives give mashed potatoes a tangy flavor. For other potato options, see our recipes for Cheesy Potatoes and Roasted Garlic Mashed Potatoes.

chive_mashed_potatoes.jpg
Credit: Sam Jones/QuinnBrein

Green Bean Casserole

To the joy of some and the lament of others, Green Bean Casserole is a holiday staple in many households. Here you’ll find a lighter homemade version that ditches the canned soup component.

green_bean_casserole_1.jpg
Credit: Sam Jones/QuinnBrein

Fall Harvest Squash Rolls

These fall harvest squash rolls are always a hit! People are surprised when they learn they’re made from squash. Another option for dinner rolls is our Cornmeal Yeast Rolls.

recipe-squash_rolls_becky_luigart_stayner.jpg
Credit: Becky Luigart-Stayner

Roasted Brussels Sprouts With Shallots and Bacon

If you’re not sure about Brussels sprouts, roast them and you’ll never look back. Brussels sprouts, bacon, and shallots is one of the most delicious flavor combinations. Another reader favorite for the holidays is Creamed Brussels Sprouts.

recipe-roastedbrusselssproutsrecipe.jpg
Credit: Becky Luigart-Stayner

Vegetarian Dishes

Curried Butternut Squash and Rice

This colorful butternut squash and rice recipe showcases the flavor of fall’s harvest in an easy yet deeply satisfying vegetarian (and vegan) meal.

shutterstock_485130997_full_width.jpg
Credit: Sergey Fati/Shutterstock

Roasted Autumn Vegetables

Hearty root vegetables are especially phenomenal when roasted. All you really need is olive oil and seasoning and voila! 

Serve over lentils with fresh parsley for garnish. 

recipe-autumn-roasted-vegetables.jpg
Credit: Becky Luigart-Stayner

Pumpkin Macaroni and Cheese

This Pumpkin Macaroni and Cheese recipe was an entry in our Old Farmer’s Almanac Reader Recipe Contest using pumpkin. Though it did not win a prize, it got many thumbs up!

shutterstock_347710118_full_width.jpg
Credit: Koss13/Shutterstock

Sweet Potato Lentil Coconut Curry

This Sweet Potato Lentil Coconut Curry is hearty, warming, colorful, and very adaptable!

recipe-sweet-potato-recipe-winners_2.jpg
Credit: Becky Luigart-Stayner

Anything strike your fancy? To find recipes for the complete Thanksgiving meal (from turkey to pumpkin pie), see our Best Thanksgiving Recipes.

Reader Comments

Leave a Comment

North America’s first thanksgiving.

The first thanksgiving was in Newfoundland in 1578.